• Latest
how do i know i exis

How do I know I exist?

March 28, 2023
django web applications in python

Mastering Django: The Ultimate Guide to Building Web Applications

January 20, 2023
the idiot Fyodor Dostoevsky

The Idiot by Fyodor Dostoevsky: A Comprehensive Study Guide

January 20, 2023
nietzsche quotes

15 Friedrich Nietzsche Quotes for the Insane 

January 16, 2023
born to philosophize forced to work

Born to Philosophize, Forced to Work

January 12, 2023
how to write like a content writer

How to Write Like A Content Writer

January 11, 2023
diogenes quotes

The Unorthodox Wisdom of the Philosopher Diogenes

January 5, 2023
indian philosophy

Philosophy Meaning in Hindi: A Comprehensive Guide

January 4, 2023
socrates robert lynd

Why According to Robert Lynd was Socrates Famed?

January 4, 2023
michel foucault rare

Michel Foucault: The Philosopher and Historian

December 15, 2022
how to become a virtual reality coach

So You Want to Be a Virtual Reality Coach? How-To Guide

November 24, 2022
how to write a philosophy paper

How to Write a Kick-Ass Philosophy Paper

November 24, 2022
philosophical evolution fouaad.com

Mystical Tendencies in Philosophical Evolution

November 24, 2022
Tesla powerwall price, cost, lifespan, capacity

Tesla Powerwall Guide: Price, Capacity, Lifespan, Review

November 18, 2022
Alph Body Language

Alpha Body Language: How to Use It to Your Advantage

November 17, 2022
characteristics of personality

How to Identify the Personality of a Person: Characteristics of Personality

November 17, 2022
depression and anger

Depression and Anger: How They’re Linked and What You Can Do About It

November 16, 2022
traits of psychopaths

Wicked Ways Psychopaths Manipulate Their Victims

November 16, 2022
How to read manga

Manga Madness: A How-To Guide For Reading Manga

November 14, 2022
10-Gmail-Hidden-Features-Only-Nerds-Know-and-Use

10 Gmail Hidden Features Only Nerds Know and Use

November 13, 2022
how long does tesla battery last

Top 21 Tesla Battery Questions Answered: (Updated 2022)

November 18, 2022
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un poses with sharpshooters of the Air and Anti-Aircraft Force in North Korea

North Korea’s Strict Rule Regime: Why It Works

November 13, 2022
north korean millitary facts

16 Bizarre Facts About the North Korean Military

November 18, 2022
peter singer famine relief argument

     Obliged or Not? Peter Singer’s Account

November 18, 2022
John-Rawls Difference principle

Kant’s Account of Moral Worth and John Rawls’s Difference Principle

March 30, 2023
free will

Meditating Free Will, Determinism, Fatalism, Existentialism, etc

November 10, 2022
belrussian female army parade

Uncertain Global Peace

November 6, 2022
Fouaad
  • Home
  • Philosophy
    • Theory
    • Books
  • World
    • Politics
    • War
  • Tech
    • Firmware
    • Hardware
  • How-To
    • Life
    • Work
  • Home
  • Philosophy
    • Theory
    • Books
  • World
    • Politics
    • War
  • Tech
    • Firmware
    • Hardware
  • How-To
    • Life
    • Work
No Result
View All Result
Fouaad
how do i know i exis

How do I know I exist?

Do I exist? If so, how do I know that I exist? If I do not exist, then who is asking these questions; and from whom? 

fouaad by fouaad
March 28, 2023
in Philosophy, Theory
791 50
WhatsappShare on FacebookShare on TwitterPin itEmail

Self-identity or the knowledge of one’s existence is a seemingly obvious question with very few (logically) satisfying answers.  The 18th-century Scottish philosopher David Hume argued that there is no such thing as a self or personal identity. What we call our identity, for Hume, is the mere collection of perceptions that are produced on account of our experiences. In his magnum opus, a treatise on human nature, he famously said that “the identity that we ascribe to things is only a fictitious one, established by the mind, not a peculiar nature belonging to what we’re talking about”. 

You will learn:

  • What to ask?
  • The Question
  • Conclusion

In this rather short piece, I argue that while I do not have the certain knowledge to affirm my existence, I have probable reason to believe as such. Rene Descartes argued that because we can think, or in other words, perceive ourselves, therefore we must exist – “cogito ergo sum’. He further maintains in his book Meditations on First Philosophy, that even if our perception of self-identity was induced by a mighty demon, we would need to have a “mind”, and therefore – we would need to exist; “exist”.

René Descartes, oil on oak by Frans Hals
René Descartes, oil on oak by Frans Hals, c. 1649; in the National Gallery of Denmark.

Evidently, Descartes and Hume have contrasting opinions on the existence of the self but neither argument is invalid (typical of philosophical theories). Hume’s arguments do not deny the existence of self-identity but rather deny the existence of a ‘unified self’ (Roth, 2000). Meaning, he argues that what we call self, is an ever-changing entity and is not fixed for anyone to point out, ‘this is me’. Whereas Descrates’ argument is concerned with self-identity in general. Meaning that the self may be or in fact. is a changing entity but it exists – regardless of its dynamic nature.

What to ask?

To say that I exist is logically too demanding a proposition and our inquiries on the subject matter are stuck on paradoxes. However, we can claim that we exist, not as unified selves but as thinking beings whose existence by nature has the potential to change over time. One might ask, what logical reasons do we have to support the claim that we exist? 

The reason to believe in the existence of sense, in general, is what Descartes proposes in the Meditations on First Philosophy, “I think therefore I am.” To reiterate, because we have the ability to think, we exist. But how can we know that the thinking being we are addressing is us? We know because we can address it. Even if it is a hallucination or any other form of false belief, we are in fact addressing an entity. Meaning, the self may be different than what we think it is, but it is, even if we deny its existence, it is we, or “I” that is denying the existence of “my” self-identity. 

How do we know something to be true? The primary faculty that we have to answer this question is our rational mind. And then we have our senses. Our sense experiences, after being rationalized by our minds, shape our perceptions. We can doubt our perceptions for valid reasons and in this case, we can and should doubt our self-identity (Williams, 2014).

The Question

Moreover, the question, of how I know if I exist as a unified self, has a predicament. For instance, the question presupposes that a person already has the knowledge of what it means to exist. And if one already had the knowledge, they must exist. The question has this presupposition, meaning that it has set conditions for something to be true in advance. The question makes this assumption otherwise, it is not plausible to imagine that we will know exactly how we exist. Because, as mentioned, our minds rationalize our sense experience and then believe a certain thing to be true based on a cause-and-effect relationship. However, in this case, we cannot possibly say with certainty that X is a unified self. 

However, Descartes in ‘Meditations on the First Philosophy’ concludes that we exist because God has allowed us to. He needed this explanation and came up with it because, without a cause-and-effect relationship, it was not possible for him to believe it to be true. 

Conclusion

Finally, we cannot deduce concrete evidence for anything to be true, including our self-identity and we cannot have certain knowledge because the cause-and-effect relationship, which is the most important and reliable way to be certain about our knowledge, cannot always be satisfied. But we can be doubtful. And we can exist, even in doubt. 

References

Descartes, R., & Veitch, J. (1641). Meditations on First Philosophy. Independently published.

Hume, D. (1739). A Treatise on Human Nature. Franklin Classics.

Roth, A. S. (2000). What was Hume’s Problem with Personal Identity? Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 61(1), 91. https://doi.org/10.2307/2653404

Williams, B. (2014). Descartes. Descartes: Pure Inquiry. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315747439

fouaad

fouaad

The author is an expert palm reader and an occasional writer. Reads Dostoevsky to ridicule Nietzsche and writes philosophy to ridcule himself. This blog is his creation and a testimony to his penchant for design.

Related Posts

the idiot Fyodor Dostoevsky
Books

The Idiot by Fyodor Dostoevsky: A Comprehensive Study Guide

January 20, 2023
nietzsche quotes
Books

15 Friedrich Nietzsche Quotes for the Insane 

January 16, 2023
born to philosophize forced to work
How-To

Born to Philosophize, Forced to Work

January 12, 2023
diogenes quotes
Philosophy

The Unorthodox Wisdom of the Philosopher Diogenes

January 5, 2023
indian philosophy
Books

Philosophy Meaning in Hindi: A Comprehensive Guide

January 4, 2023
socrates robert lynd
Philosophy

Why According to Robert Lynd was Socrates Famed?

January 4, 2023
  • About
  • Write for us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
All articles by Fouaad.
All articles by Aly.

© 2023 fouaad.com. All Rights Reserved!

No Result
View All Result
  • Philosophy
    • Theory
    • Books
  • World
    • War
    • Politics
  • Tech
    • Firmware
    • Hardware
  • How-To
    • Life
    • Work

© 2023 fouaad.com. All Rights Reserved!

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Sign Up with Facebook
OR

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.