• Latest
John-Rawls Difference principle

Kant’s Account of Moral Worth and John Rawls’s Difference Principle

March 30, 2023
django web applications in python

Mastering Django: The Ultimate Guide to Building Web Applications

January 20, 2023
the idiot Fyodor Dostoevsky

The Idiot by Fyodor Dostoevsky: A Comprehensive Study Guide

January 20, 2023
nietzsche quotes

15 Friedrich Nietzsche Quotes for the Insane 

January 16, 2023
born to philosophize forced to work

Born to Philosophize, Forced to Work

January 12, 2023
how to write like a content writer

How to Write Like A Content Writer

January 11, 2023
diogenes quotes

The Unorthodox Wisdom of the Philosopher Diogenes

January 5, 2023
indian philosophy

Philosophy Meaning in Hindi: A Comprehensive Guide

January 4, 2023
socrates robert lynd

Why According to Robert Lynd was Socrates Famed?

January 4, 2023
michel foucault rare

Michel Foucault: The Philosopher and Historian

December 15, 2022
how to become a virtual reality coach

So You Want to Be a Virtual Reality Coach? How-To Guide

November 24, 2022
how to write a philosophy paper

How to Write a Kick-Ass Philosophy Paper

November 24, 2022
philosophical evolution fouaad.com

Mystical Tendencies in Philosophical Evolution

November 24, 2022
Tesla powerwall price, cost, lifespan, capacity

Tesla Powerwall Guide: Price, Capacity, Lifespan, Review

November 18, 2022
Alph Body Language

Alpha Body Language: How to Use It to Your Advantage

November 17, 2022
characteristics of personality

How to Identify the Personality of a Person: Characteristics of Personality

November 17, 2022
depression and anger

Depression and Anger: How They’re Linked and What You Can Do About It

November 16, 2022
traits of psychopaths

Wicked Ways Psychopaths Manipulate Their Victims

November 16, 2022
How to read manga

Manga Madness: A How-To Guide For Reading Manga

November 14, 2022
10-Gmail-Hidden-Features-Only-Nerds-Know-and-Use

10 Gmail Hidden Features Only Nerds Know and Use

November 13, 2022
how long does tesla battery last

Top 21 Tesla Battery Questions Answered: (Updated 2022)

November 18, 2022
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un poses with sharpshooters of the Air and Anti-Aircraft Force in North Korea

North Korea’s Strict Rule Regime: Why It Works

November 13, 2022
north korean millitary facts

16 Bizarre Facts About the North Korean Military

November 18, 2022
peter singer famine relief argument

     Obliged or Not? Peter Singer’s Account

November 18, 2022
how do i know i exis

How do I know I exist?

March 28, 2023
free will

Meditating Free Will, Determinism, Fatalism, Existentialism, etc

November 10, 2022
belrussian female army parade

Uncertain Global Peace

November 6, 2022
Fouaad
  • Home
  • Philosophy
    • Theory
    • Books
  • World
    • Politics
    • War
  • Tech
    • Firmware
    • Hardware
  • How-To
    • Life
    • Work
  • Home
  • Philosophy
    • Theory
    • Books
  • World
    • Politics
    • War
  • Tech
    • Firmware
    • Hardware
  • How-To
    • Life
    • Work
No Result
View All Result
Fouaad
John-Rawls Difference principle
Trending

Kant’s Account of Moral Worth and John Rawls’s Difference Principle

Your actions may be right but are they morally worth it? Kant’s account.

fouaad by fouaad
March 30, 2023
in Books, Philosophy, Theory
0 0
WhatsappShare on FacebookShare on TwitterPin itEmail

Kant argues in the critique of pure reason that an action might be morally just but it does not necessarily have to have moral value. Meaning; that not all actions hold the same moral worth. It is noteworthy that this theory applies to actions of the same moral significance. 

You will learn:

  • How impartial can you really be? Utilitarian Approach.
  • Can you use people as means of self-interest? Is it even possible?
  • John Rawl’s Difference Principle

 For instance, if I testify in a court of law and tell the truth to save an innocent accused’s life, that action holds moral value for Kant. Similarly, if I give the same testimony for the same accused, however, in a court simulation – which does not have real consequences and thereby my testimony does not save the innocent’s life – this action will be morally acceptable but would not hold moral worth. 

I agree with Kant on the moral value of actions because of the fact that a truly moral person would choose to do the right thing regardless of the consequences. This is the moral standard one must adhere to. If I were telling the truth in the first scenario of the case mentioned above, I would have either done it because I knew and believed it to be the right thing to do or I told the truth because of an external force. If the latter is the reason for my moral action, I am most likely to not tell the truth in other such circumstances. This means that my overall moral worth is likely to drop in the future and the said action, therefore, does not hold any moral worth. 

How impartial can you really be? Utilitarian Approach.

John Stuart Mill says that it is important for every member of a utilitarian society to be impartial when making decisions that could determine the happiness of the person himself. Meaning a utilitarian should not think of only himself but of the entire society. For their own happiness, a person must not compromise on the Principle of Utility.

It is difficult and against human nature for anyone to be impartial insofar as to sacrifice their own happiness over other people’s. But there is one way that has the potential to make everyone benevolent at such high standards, and that is to have a rational understanding of what it means to adhere strictly to this utilitarian principle. Understanding this principle and its meaning means accepting wholeheartedly, that the greater good for a greater number of people is as moral as we can be. 

All human beings are born free and they have a right to their life – how they want to lead it and whether they want to live it or not.

Mill’s claim advocates for the altruism of the highest standards and it cannot be objected to. However, in specific situations in which strictly adhering to this principle does not lead to the broader utilitarian principle of the greater good for the greater number of people, it will be a blind path to take. But in situations where it is certain that one’s impartiality will lead to the satisfaction of the fundamental utilitarian argument, it is an unobjectionable proposition. 

Can you use people as means of self-interest? Is it even possible?

It is possible to treat someone partially as a means. Human history, including the present times, is full of examples where individuals have used other individuals for their self-interest. One glaring example is Russian President Vladimir Putin’s war in Ukraine at the hands of his conscripts. He is using young conscripts to further his interest. This example is also quintessential to justify that using someone as a means to get what you want is unjustified. 

I justify my argument with a rather broader concept – Freedom.  All human beings are born free and they have a right to their life – how they want to lead it and whether they want to live it or not. This basic right to living a free life makes us human and treating someone partially as a means is akin to infringing on their most basic right – ergo, infringing on their right to be human.  Furthermore, it might inflict great suffering on the ‘victim’, as evident from the Russian conscripts fighting Putin’s war in Ukraine.   

Here, one could counterargue that it is possible to treat someone partially as a means with due consent – and in that case, I would argue, it is moral. If a person willingly and in the right state of mind,  knowing all the ramifications of their decision, wants to be used – they too have the right to choose. They may do so and one would not have any objection. 

John Rawl’s Difference Principle

According to Rawls’ difference principle, social and economic inequalities are to be justified if they are to satisfy two conditions. The first condition Rawls proposes is the following: should the difference occur despite equal and fair opportunities for all, it can be justified. And the second condition states that the opportunities are to benefit the least advantaged.

In the case of the economic difference between Jeff Bezos and the average Amazon warehouse worker, we can establish that both of them enjoy the same liberties when it comes to taking action for economic success. However, it is also pertinent to mention that the average Amazon warehouse worker may not have had the same financial background to ensure fair results of their action – which begs the question, how do we know, or verify, whether people have the same opportunities to gain financial and economic success justifiable? On account of the countless variables and subjectivity involved in the case, we cannot in fact verify whether people have access to equal opportunities. 

This leads to pointing out the inconsistency in Rawls’ difference principle but to answer the moral justification of economic and social inequality according to the said principle in the context of Bezos and the average Amazon warehouse worker, the inequality is justifiable.

fouaad

fouaad

The author is an expert palm reader and an occasional writer. Reads Dostoevsky to ridicule Nietzsche and writes philosophy to ridcule himself. This blog is his creation and a testimony to his penchant for design.

Related Posts

the idiot Fyodor Dostoevsky
Books

The Idiot by Fyodor Dostoevsky: A Comprehensive Study Guide

January 20, 2023
nietzsche quotes
Books

15 Friedrich Nietzsche Quotes for the Insane 

January 16, 2023
born to philosophize forced to work
How-To

Born to Philosophize, Forced to Work

January 12, 2023
diogenes quotes
Philosophy

The Unorthodox Wisdom of the Philosopher Diogenes

January 5, 2023
indian philosophy
Books

Philosophy Meaning in Hindi: A Comprehensive Guide

January 4, 2023
socrates robert lynd
Philosophy

Why According to Robert Lynd was Socrates Famed?

January 4, 2023
  • About
  • Write for us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
All articles by Fouaad.
All articles by Aly.

© 2023 fouaad.com. All Rights Reserved!

No Result
View All Result
  • Philosophy
    • Theory
    • Books
  • World
    • War
    • Politics
  • Tech
    • Firmware
    • Hardware
  • How-To
    • Life
    • Work

© 2023 fouaad.com. All Rights Reserved!

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Sign Up with Facebook
OR

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.