• Latest
free will

Meditating Free Will, Determinism, Fatalism, Existentialism, etc

November 10, 2022
deontology vs utilitarianism ethical theories

Utilitarianism vs Deontology: A Comparison of Two Ethical Theories

May 16, 2023
tesla powerwall 3

Ultimate Guide to Tesla Powerwall 3: Price, Specs, Release Date

May 11, 2023
django web applications in python

Mastering Django: The Ultimate Guide to Building Web Applications

January 20, 2023
the idiot Fyodor Dostoevsky

The Idiot by Fyodor Dostoevsky: A Comprehensive Study Guide

January 20, 2023
nietzsche quotes

15 Friedrich Nietzsche Quotes for the Insane 

January 16, 2023
born to philosophize forced to work

Born to Philosophize, Forced to Work

January 12, 2023
how to write like a content writer

How to Write Like A Content Writer

January 11, 2023
diogenes quotes

The Unorthodox Wisdom of the Philosopher Diogenes

January 5, 2023
indian philosophy

Philosophy Meaning in Hindi: A Comprehensive Guide

January 4, 2023
socrates robert lynd

Why According to Robert Lynd was Socrates Famed?

January 4, 2023
michel foucault rare

Michel Foucault: The Philosopher and Historian

December 15, 2022
how to become a virtual reality coach

So You Want to Be a Virtual Reality Coach? How-To Guide

November 24, 2022
how to write a philosophy paper

How to Write a Kick-Ass Philosophy Paper

November 24, 2022
philosophical evolution fouaad.com

Mystical Tendencies in Philosophical Evolution

November 24, 2022
Tesla powerwall price, cost, lifespan, capacity

Tesla Powerwall Guide: Price, Capacity, Lifespan, Review

November 18, 2022
Alph Body Language

Alpha Body Language: How to Use It to Your Advantage

November 17, 2022
characteristics of personality

How to Identify the Personality of a Person: Characteristics of Personality

November 17, 2022
depression and anger

Depression and Anger: How They’re Linked and What You Can Do About It

November 16, 2022
traits of psychopaths

Wicked Ways Psychopaths Manipulate Their Victims

November 16, 2022
How to read manga

Manga Madness: A How-To Guide For Reading Manga

November 14, 2022
10-Gmail-Hidden-Features-Only-Nerds-Know-and-Use

10 Gmail Hidden Features Only Nerds Know and Use

November 13, 2022
how long does tesla battery last

Top 21 Tesla Battery Questions Answered: (Updated 2022)

May 15, 2023
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un poses with sharpshooters of the Air and Anti-Aircraft Force in North Korea

North Korea’s Strict Rule Regime: Why It Works

November 13, 2022
north korean millitary facts

16 Bizarre Facts About the North Korean Military

November 18, 2022
peter singer famine relief argument

     Obliged or Not? Peter Singer’s Account

November 18, 2022
John-Rawls Difference principle

Kant’s Account of Moral Worth and John Rawls’s Difference Principle

March 30, 2023
how do i know i exis

How do I know I exist?

March 28, 2023
belrussian female army parade

Uncertain Global Peace

November 6, 2022
Fouaad
  • Home
  • Philosophy
    • Theory
    • Books
  • World
    • Politics
    • War
  • Tech
    • Firmware
    • Hardware
  • How-To
    • Life
    • Work
  • Home
  • Philosophy
    • Theory
    • Books
  • World
    • Politics
    • War
  • Tech
    • Firmware
    • Hardware
  • How-To
    • Life
    • Work
No Result
View All Result
Fouaad
free will

Meditating Free Will, Determinism, Fatalism, Existentialism, etc

Am I willingly writing this sentence or is it the sequence of infinite events of the universe’s past that are causing this action?

fouaad by fouaad
November 10, 2022
in Philosophy, Theory
782 59
WhatsappShare on FacebookShare on TwitterPin itEmail

The problem with the method

Am I willingly writing this sentence or is it the sequence of infinite events of the universe’s past that are causing this action? This question can be answered through a simple experiment. That is, can I stop writing if I wish to? The answer is yes, indeed I can but I choose to write for I have the freedom to choose what I want. Also, what is causing my wish to stop or keep writing? Is it the sequence of infinite events of the universe’s past or is it caused currently due to my contemplation of the problem?

You will learn:

  • The problem with the method
  • Determinism
  • Fatalism
  • Predestination
  • Libertarianism, existentialism, and the Law of Karma
    • Libertarianism
    • Existentialism
    • Law of Karma – The Moral Side
      • References

 

At a glance, this simple thought experiment seems to convince an observer, however, there is a conundrum which is: What if this thought experiment was also caused by the infinite events that have happened and are still happening since the birth of the universe? What if everything we do or say, or write is predetermined? 

To avoid paradoxes (love them though), I will disregard these objections because such objections can be raised against any explanation or answer of free will on account of the lack of a falsifiable method of verifying whether an act is spontaneous and willing – as opposed to determined by the conditions of the past.

Determinism

Determinism is the doctrine that posits all of our decisions are ultimately determined by conditions that are not in our control and are caused by the history of the universe. Meaning if I am studying for a bachelor’s degree, I am doing so on account of the events of my past. And my past includes not only my past but the entire past of the universe. The universe was created, it cooled down, life emerged, species evolved, and one species evolved into what we call today humans, humans then created institutions as part of organized life which requires me to get a college degree to survive or for other reasons. 

Now the problem with this theory is that it entirely disregards the present. The whim. It simply ignores the fact that one chooses to act in a certain manner out of one’s own will. From a philosophical lens, to say that everything is caused by the events of the past seems too big a generalization that fails to justify its proposition.  

Fatalism

“Fatalism is the belief that events are predetermined by some impersonal power (Kessler, 2015)”. Meaning that the occurrences in one’s life are not influenced by the actions of the person but are determined by external forces. Arthur Schopenhauer puts it in The World as Will and Idea, “man can do what he wants but cannot want what he wants (1844)”. What the great pessimist philosopher says is that the freedom of will is an illusion. Meaning, that what we do thinking we are doing willingly is a mere illusion and in reality, it is the conditions of the time that are causing our actions. Furthermore, Schopenhauer also means that the human mind is conditioned to believe its actions to be purely its own. When in fact, the actions are the result of the conditions. 

Since one cannot verify the validity of this proposition, it cannot be regarded as a cogent argument against the freedom of the will. 

Predestination

 As opposed to fatalism, predestination is the “belief that occurrences are determined by a personal power (Kessler, 2015)”. This theory posits that destiny can be influenced by the efforts of an individual. Moreover, it empowers an individual similar to the theories that are discussed in the later parts of the essay.

Libertarianism, existentialism, and the Law of Karma

Libertarianism, existentialism, and the law of karma emancipate the person from the presumed slavery of a determined or a predestined world and this freedom comes with the responsibility and the ability to choose one’s own destiny. 

Libertarianism

Libertarianism is a political philosophy that argues against the control of the state over the private lives of its citizens and maintains that a state should intervene in a person’s private life only when it is a threat to the well-being of the collective society.

In the context of free will, libertarianism advocates for the exercise of the free will of people. 

A premise that supports free will is inherent in the fundamental proposition of libertarianism. This theory is based on the premise that humans can and should choose the conduct of their life as they see fit, as long as it does not infringe on other people’s rights or harm other people. This means that the stakes for which libertarianism advocates make it a precondition for us to believe in the freedom of the will.

In fact, the libertarian philosopher John Stuart Mill believed the free will to be “an individual’s freedom to choose his own form of happiness, that could override the Utilitarian pleasure-pain principle” (1859).

Existentialism

 Existentialism is the philosophical tradition that argues for freedom and decision as foundational characteristics of human nature. Jean-Paul Sartre puts in Existentialism is a Humanism, “Man is condemned to be free; because once thrown into the world, he is responsible for everything he does. It is up to you to give [life] a meaning” (Sartre, 2007). The tradition of existentialism is founded on the premise that freedom and decision are the fundamental parts of human nature and that they should be exercised. Furthermore, the existentialist approach advocates for the exercise of the freedoms to which man is condemned. 

Another core concept of existentialist theory is the belief in the rationality of human nature. 

Law of Karma – The Moral Side

The law of Karma is a theory that maintains that the true thoughts of an individual are realized and their actions, whether good or bad, have consequences for them as well. This law too supports the freedom of the will in a subtle manner. Knowing that one will not be immune from the ramifications of one’s actions will hold the person responsible and therefore, prevent the person from committing evil deeds.

It certainly does not justify the freedom of the will but is a plausible reason for many to believe in the subject matter. The reason is the moral responsibility of people for their actions. Because if people are not to be held responsible for their actions, the diabolical part of human nature will dominate the world, and therefore, an external restrainer in the name of Karma is needed. 

References

Kessler, G. E. (2015). Voices of Wisdom: A Multicultural Philosophy Reader (9th ed.). Wadsworth Publishing.

Mill, J. S. (1859). On Liberty. Independently published.

Sartre, J. (1946). Existentialism Is a Humanism (Annotated ed.). Yale University Press.

Schopenhauer, A. (1844). Schopenhauer: The World as Will and Representation (The Cambridge Edition of the Works of Schopenhauer). Cambridge University Press.

 

fouaad

fouaad

The author is an expert palm reader and an occasional writer. Reads Dostoevsky to ridicule Nietzsche and writes philosophy to ridcule himself. This blog is his creation and a testimony to his penchant for design.

Related Posts

deontology vs utilitarianism ethical theories
Books

Utilitarianism vs Deontology: A Comparison of Two Ethical Theories

May 16, 2023
the idiot Fyodor Dostoevsky
Books

The Idiot by Fyodor Dostoevsky: A Comprehensive Study Guide

January 20, 2023
nietzsche quotes
Books

15 Friedrich Nietzsche Quotes for the Insane 

January 16, 2023
born to philosophize forced to work
How-To

Born to Philosophize, Forced to Work

January 12, 2023
diogenes quotes
Philosophy

The Unorthodox Wisdom of the Philosopher Diogenes

January 5, 2023
indian philosophy
Books

Philosophy Meaning in Hindi: A Comprehensive Guide

January 4, 2023
  • About
  • Write for us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
All articles by Fouaad.
All articles by Aly.

© 2023 fouaad.com. All Rights Reserved!

No Result
View All Result
  • Philosophy
    • Theory
    • Books
  • World
    • War
    • Politics
  • Tech
    • Firmware
    • Hardware
  • How-To
    • Life
    • Work

© 2023 fouaad.com. All Rights Reserved!

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.